The distinction between vertebrate and invertebrate may be artificial and is certainly
controversial. Invertebrates are defined as organisms belonging to the Kingdom
Animalia-multicellular, eukaryotic (cells with cellular organelles present), heterotrophic
(do not produce their own food), and lack cell walls-that do not contain a vertebral
column. Distinguishing between invertebrates and vertebrates is controversial in part
because it separates less than 5% of all animals and suggests a strong bias towards
organisms that are similar to humans. Further controversy arises from the fact that all
animals are composed of multiple species. Thus, even the simplest animals-vertebrate
or invertebrate-are a conglomerate of numerous species. Dr. Lynn Margulis suggests
that the merging of numerous species is actually necessary for all complex life, stated
formally as the theory of symbiogenesis. The theory of symbiogenis is supported by the
fact that every know animal is composed of multiple species (about 10% of human dry mass
is non-vertebrate species), survival is know to depend upon these multiple species, and even
the cellular organelles of eukaryotes may have arisen from a symbiotic relationship among
prokaryotes, the endosymbiotic theory. Thus, dividing the animal world into invertebrates and
vertebrates does not take into account the many other species that make up all higher
organisms-ignoring what may be a critical feature of all organisms-and represents our bias
towards things that are like ourselves.
Things I would look for in a complete answer.
1 point: Statement of the problem
1 point: Correct definition of Kingdom Animalia
2 points: Explanations of terms
1 point: Definition of invertebrates
1 point: Statement why controversial
1 point: Sentence concerning the biased view of dividing the animal
world into vertebrates and invertebrates
1 point: Definition of symbiogenesis
1 point: Major proponent of symbiogenesis is Lynn Margullis
3 points: Evidence for symbiogenesis
2 points: brief explanation of endosymbiotic theory
2 points: accurate summary statement
4 points: clarity of thought and overall organization
Total points possible = 20